Sufficient unto the day is the evil thereof

Should You Write Your Own Wikipedia Entry?

In PR, Social media, Wiki on June 17, 2007 at 7:53 pm

Update: Considering Virgil Griffith’s Wikipedia Scanner, which shows which companies have edited their own entries by comparing edits to IP addresses there’s even more reason to leave the editing of your entry to others. Here’s the Wired story, “See Who’s Editing Wikipedia.”

***

It’s not unheard of for me to disagree with my friend Marshall Kirkpatrick. However, it’s usually he who is encouraging more restraint. In this case, Marshall suggested, in a recent post, that someone who wants to write an entry on a subject that they are connected with should do so, so long as they make it clear what their relationship is to the subject. In this case, I have to disagree, at least when it comes to writing, or materially altering, an entry about yourself, your organization or your company.

While working for the Oregon Shakespeare Festival, someone noticed that the entry for the festival was incomplete. I suggested that we ask for volunteers, people who are interested in the festival but do not work for it, to augment that entry. I further suggested that we provide any volunteers who come forward with whatever information they felt they needed but then leave them to it. My feeling was that if they wrote something untrue, we could contact them for a correction or, worse come to worse, we could make the correction ourselves, but only as a last resort. The festival’s leadership disagreed. Their intent was to actively guide the work of these “volunteers,” to tell them what needed to be written and how they should write it and if that leadership did not approve, they would change the entry themselves. I disagreed strongly with this approach of gaming Wikipedia and it was one of the elements that lead to my parting ways with them.

Here’s my thinking: Considering the innate skepticism of readers, based both on the problems in journalism (both overt problems, such as the outright lies published by people like Stephen Glass and Jason Blair, and the implied shortcomings, such as alleged ideological biases) as well as problems with authorship and self-authorship in Wikipedia itself (Wales, Curry, Segenthaler), it is better to take no direct action regarding your own entry. If you author, or alter, your own entry, that entry will always be regarded with skepticism by readers and you will open yourself up to charges of cynical gaming of the medium. Why take the chance when there are alternatives open to you?

That’s why I disagree with Marshall and advise any person, organization or company to neither author nor alter their own Wikipedia entry.

,

Advertisements
  1. I thought about creating a wiki-page as shameful self-promotion but couldn’t even figure out how to start a new page on Wikipedia!

  2. […] I have a thing against being involved in the creation, or substantial revision or addition, of a Wikipedia entry involving […]

  3. Hah. Good post. Just wrote about doing your own Wikipedia article on my blog today: http://www.daniboy.com/blog/?p=126

  4. Edelsteine und kostbare Jadestatue wurde in der Schweiz (CH) detektiert

    Im Jahr 2008 gelang mit unserem Ortungsgerät Garrett GTI2500 ein erstaunlicher Fund in Florida, den Vereinigten Staaten von Amerika. Eine Gruppe von Schatzsuchern detektierte eine vergrabene Messingkanone, die mit verschiedenen Edelsteinen und Schmuckstücken gefüllt war. Daneben wurde noch eine wunderschöne Jadestatue gefunden.



    garret metalldetektor gti2500 garet metalldetektoren

    Hier einige Auszüge aus den E-Mails des Kunden (übersetzt aus dem Englischen) vom 22. und 27. März 2008:

    “Letzten Monat haben wir eine vergrabene Messingkanone auf einm Berg in der Schweiz gefunden. Darin waren Edelsteine und goldene Ketten.

    “Die angefügten Dateien zeigen einige der gefundenen Sachen. Die Jadestatue befand sich im Boden neben der Kanone, sie war zu groß und passte nicht hinein. Die Statue ist 12 Zoll lang und 6 Zoll hoch und wiegt ca. 20 Pfund. Das andere Bild zeigt einige Edelsteine. Hinter den großen gelben Edelstein haben wir eine Viertel-Dollar Münze in Bild gelegt, um die Größenverhältnisse darzustellen.”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: